Directed by Neveldine/Taylor
Written by Neveldine/Taylor
Starring Gerard Butler, Michael C. Hall, and Kyra Sedgwick
Running Time: 1 hour and 35 minutes
Rated: R
Honestly, Mark Neveldine and Brian Taylor are guilty pleasure kings. Crank was one of the most kick ass movies I have ever seen. It was one of the most fun movies I have ever seen and automatically fell in love with these film makers. When Gamer came out, I knew I had to see it, but with all the negative response from the critics, I decided to wait for DVD. I think overall, that was a good decision. While Gamer does provide girls, guns, and gore like it promises, it fails to provide the same flair that Neveldine and Taylor have shown and provided in their previous films. The guilty pleasure-ness of Gamer is not there, and the hyperkinetic action and no shot lasts longer than five seconds approach eventually sinks this ship.
The direction by Neveldine and Taylor is unfortunately not as good as they usually provide. It seems less inspired than usual, but still, some of their flair and style is still their. Some of the violence and action they provide is really fun and many of the scenes get you really into the action, as Crank did perfectly. Also, I thought the musical number there was hilarious. These guys really do know how to make a guy's guy movie. This one has everything your typical male movie goer looks for. Hot, naked girls, crazy action, lots of blood, and in this one, even a plot about video games. Each scene feels like a dare each film maker provided to each other, but unfortunately it doesn't work.
The filming is very eccentric and their are so many cuts that it is hard to keep up sometimes. As seen in the other Neveldine/Taylor movies before, the scenes are very exaggerated and over the top, but in Gamer, it sometimes doesn't work. Sometimes the action is a little too hyperkinetic, and overall, the directing turns out just average.
The acting in Gamer is better than average, surprisingly enough. Although the editing is frantic, you can tell the actors put in an effort with Gamer. Gerard Butler is coming up to be one of the biggest action stars in the world, and he does a good job of being a badass, man's man, stud in Gamer. Ludacris, whose music I love, Kyra Sedgwick, and the always great Michael C. Hall, are all very good in their roles. Even Logan Lerman, who will be the lead role in Percy Jackson, provides a good performance. No one here does an amazing job, but it is good enough to believe in the characters.
The writing was pretty all over the place by Neveldine and Taylor. Writing is barely needed in this film, because these two guys seem to just do cool stuff with the camera and forget about logic. It works with their other films, but with this one, it kind of goes a little TOO over the top. For example, while Butler is trying to escape from the game, he fills up the tank of a giant truck with piss and some throw up, and manages to drive for about five miles on it. Come on. If you go with that, you should at least try to make it funny, which I was expecting more of. Going in, you get what you want, and I thought the ending was well executed and really let you feel good about Gerard Butler's character at the end, but the plot itself was very weak. The characters weren't fully developed, and in the end, the script is weak.
Overall, Gamer fails to live up to its potential. I was expecting a guilty pleasure action movie, and I got some of that, but in the end, this movie turned out to be way too illogical and irrational to believe. Neveldine and Taylor's last movie, Crank, was at least really fun and kept you laughing the whole time, but Gamer's obvious social commentary, lack of tension, hyper-kinetic action, plodding narrative, drags this one's potential down to a rotten rating. Gamer features a little too much brawn over brain, which in the end sinks the ship.
